An Open Statement from Rep. Ron Paul:
â€In 2002 I asked my House colleagues a rhetorical question with regard to the onslaught of government growth in the post-September 11 th era: Is America becoming a police state?
The question is no longer rhetorical. We are not yet living in a total police state, but it is fast approaching. The seeds of future tyranny have been sown, and many of our basic protections against government have been undermined. The atmosphere since 2001 has permitted Congress to create whole new departments and agencies that purport to make us safer- always at the expense of our liberty. But security and liberty go hand-in-hand. Members of Congress, like too many Americans, don’t understand that a society with no constraints on its government cannot be secure. History proves that societies crumble when their governments become more powerful than the people and private institutions.
Unfortunately, the new intelligence bill passed by Congress two weeks ago moves us closer to an encroaching police state by imposing the precursor to a full-fledged national ID card. Within two years, every American will need a “conforming” ID to deal with any federal agency-- including TSA at the airport.
Undoubtedly many Americans and members of Congress don’t believe America is becoming a police state, which is reasonable enough. They associate the phrase with highly visible symbols of authoritarianism like military patrols, martial law, and summary executions. But we ought to be concerned that we have laid the foundation for tyranny by making the public more docile, more accustomed to government bullying, and more accepting of arbitrary authority- all in the name of security. Our love for liberty above all has been so diminished that we tolerate intrusions into our privacy that would have been abhorred just a few years ago. We tolerate inconveniences and infringements upon our liberties in a manner that reflects poorly on our great national character of rugged individualism. American history, at least in part, is a history of people who don’t like being told what to do. Yet we are increasingly empowering the federal government and its agents to run our lives.
Terror, fear, and crises like 9-11 are used to achieve complacency and obedience, especially when citizens are deluded into believing they are still a free people. The loss of liberty, we are assured, will be minimal, short-lived, and necessary. Many citizens believe that once the war on terror is over, restrictions on their liberties will be reversed. But this war is undeclared and open-ended, with no precise enemy and no expressly stated final goal. Terrorism will never be eradicated completely; does this mean future presidents will assert extraordinary war powers indefinitely?"
To Further beg this point, one of the more unsavory aspects that has emerged from the recently released FBI documents suggests that an Executive Order actually authorized the use of torture on detainees. This email written by an "On scene commander in Baghdad," continually refers to an Executive Order that authorized the use of "sleep deprivation, stress positions, loud music, etc..." Though the White House denies that any such order exists and argues that the agent who wrote the email was mistaken, this kind of thinking is consistent with that of general counsel to the President Alberto Gonzalez, our soon to be Attorney General, who seems to view the Geneva Conventions as a quaint artifact of history and certainly not something that should restrain the movements of Bush or the United States military/intelligence community.
One of the most troubling aspects of all of this is the complete arrogance with which our public officials are conducting business. I found it particularly poignant that Rumsfeld can't be bothered to sign condolence letters to the families of fallen soldiers. What sort of vision are these people connecting with exactly? These people are not pursuing freedom and Democracy as an honorable cause, fighting the specter of tyranny and terrorism. Truth be told, WE ARE THE TERRORISTS! You, me, most likely the person sitting next to you if you're reading this in the United States. We as Americans supplied Israel with $2.16 billion in military aid in 2004, which has gone to the continual destruction of Palestinian homes, and Olive Tree orchards, because olives are obviously a significant security threat. We bought the bombs and bullets and paid the salaries of the occupying force in Iraq, leaving US with the blood of 100,000 Iraqis is on OUR hands. We created Al Qaeda, We made Osama Bin Laden, We supported Saddam, We, as Americans, have been instrumental in creating, or have benefited from the fruits of genocide, brutality, murder, and tyranny. This is our history, and there is nothing you can do about the past other than to learn from it…. Exactly, LEARN FROM IT!
September 11th was a window that we unfortunately missed. It was a moment where we could have re-evaluated our relationship with the rest of the world and realized that there are consequences to our manipulation of the rest of the world. It was an opportunity to realize that if we continue to commit acts of state-sponsored terrorism, we will become the victim of terrorism. It is not due to an irrational hatred of freedom on the part of terrorists that we were attacked and continue to be tartgeted. Bin Laden made a concise statement in the tape that he released just prior to the Presidential election. “If we hate freedom so much, why don’t we attack Sweden?” The evil doers are not nuggets of evil that sprang from the bowels of Satan to challenge us good Christian souls. They are human beings that have come from a particular context, a particular society, and in the case of the Middle East and Afghanistan, a context that has been highly manipulated by the United States for our own interests. I hope I am stating the obvious here for most of the people reading this. If such is the case, I’d like to ask you, “What have you done to save your country from tyranny today?”
Despite my meandering tirades, it seems like it would be a helpful meditation to realize that we are all in this together and that we are all equally to blame for the state of things. Likewise, it’s up to us to change the course of things.